Uncertainty in the business environment is an operational hazard that is never cleared. Leaders are mastering a new set of decision-making skills that fit the new reality, ensuring their organizations continue to thrive. - BY DAVE DESOUZA
The decision-making skills that business leaders have traditionally learned are based on a simple formula: gather data, analyze options, determine risks and how to minimize them, and make a decision. It is a methodical process, but it works best when the business environment is stable and disruptions are episodic. That does not describe the fundamental conditions today, which are very different. There is a lot written about how businesses deal with continuous change, as leaders now manage in an environment of constant uncertainty. The forces of uncertainty seem endless and include shifting trade policies, inflation, changing regulations, skills shortages, natural disasters, cybersecurity issues, evolving advanced technologies, and frequently changing consumer demand. The constant uncertainty is prompting a reconsideration of leadership decision-making processes and the relationship between leaders and their employees. Making “perfect decisions” in response to a disruptive event is shifting to making good decisions quickly and adapting as circumstances evolve, while keeping employees aligned with business goals through communication.
Learning to Accept Some Chance

One of the lessons organizational leaders are learning is that “waiting for more information” to make a decision is a practice that does not work well in a business environment of continuous uncertainty. Some of the most successful people in the world knew this many years ago, likely because they understood that uncertainty was becoming a state of being for businesses. Amazon founder Jeff Bezos said, “Most decisions should probably be made with about 70% of the information you wish you had. If you wait for 90%, in most cases, you’re probably being slow." "Thinking too much leads to paralysis by analysis… It's important to think things through, but don't use thinking as a means of avoiding action,” said Robert Herjavec, tech entrepreneur, investor, cybersecurity expert, and founder of Shark Tank.
Overthinking delays decision-making because it rests on the theory that taking as much time as necessary to gather 90% of the desired information constitutes good leadership. As uncertainty grips the business environment, this approach is not effective. B. Cade Massey, PhD, Practice Professor, Operations and Information Management at the Wharton School, explains that today’s leaders need to accept uncertainty and factor in chance, recognizing there will be unaccountable variables. He calls this the logic of chance. “This logic recognizes that there is no one “knowable” answer. When you adapt your decisions to the logic of chance, they will improve.” He recommends five action steps: acknowledge uncertainty, consider more options, take more chances, expect to be wrong, learn.
The new leadership decision-making process is quite different from the traditional one.
Strategic Resilience Through Acceptance of Uncertainty
William Reed, in “10 Strategies for Leading in Uncertain Times” points out that leaders need agility and a willingness to rethink how they lead, plan, and adapt in a world where the rules are consistently broken. The days of leadership equating to full control are gone, and agility has become essential. Reed summarized insights from researchers and executives on managing during chaos and uncertainty. Topping the list is being better prepared for the impact of political surprises. One example of resilience is investing in a diverse supply chain so that suppliers or inputs can be quickly switched in response to unexpected tariffs. Leaders should adopt a mindset that balances efficiency with the ability to create long-term value by making decisions that prepare for uncertainty.
Another important insight Reed shares is that successful leaders cannot predict the future, so they should not set an unwavering course of action. Leaders and their team members should be willing to reevaluate assumptions and change direction when they sense change is happening. Also, managers should be a source of calm by prioritizing employees' individual needs and building trust.
Traditional leadership assumes there is one good answer that can be discovered through analysis. This is one of the dangers of relying solely on artificial intelligence. It can detect patterns found in large amounts of data, but it lacks human intuition. Uncertainty invalidates the assumption of one good answer because it typically presents multiple issues or scenarios, each with a different risk level. This gray area of decision-making can be difficult to maneuver when years of leadership development and experience occurred in a more certain business environment. Instead of basing decisions on the belief there is a single correct answer, leaders learn to evaluate probabilities, evaluate scenarios, and identify plausible responses.
Leading Employees Through Uncertainty
Of course, managing uncertainty requires successfully creating an organizational culture that supports employees. Leaders need skills in creating psychological safety because employees may have serious concerns about the assumptions leaders make but are afraid to speak up. The high-pressure environment of uncertainty can alienate employees when they do not understand the new leadership decision-making process or are reluctant to share in identifying emerging risks, present contradictory information, or question ideas. Communication is crucial to ensuring employees have clear direction, work with accurate information and understand the reasoning.
An important element of adaptive leadership in an uncertain environment is encouraging constructive disagreement. Uncertainty, unlike an episode, is continuous and fluid. It presents itself over time, and employees are often the first to recognize the change as it develops. Encouraging their diverse input contributes to strategic thinking and better problem-solving.
As leaders change their perspective and change management strategies, they should also recognize the important role of employees in the decision-making process. Reinforcing adaptability as a strength can ease confusion and prevent workers from thinking their manager is indecisive.
A Future of Change
Uncertainty is not going to end. There are too many factors contributing to uncertainty, including technological innovation, geopolitical tensions, and climate risks. The most successful leaders will be those who develop new skills for making informed decisions with the information available to them, rather than with all the information they would like to have. They will know how to model and manage risks, recognizing that they will shift. In the future, leaders will need to be adaptable while maintaining the confidence of employees and all stakeholders. In the age of disruption, leadership is not about eliminating uncertainty. It is about building adaptable organizations that can thrive in any business environment.